Karlheinz Muhr Library

The Complete “Austrian School of Economics” Collection


© 2026 Karlheinz Muhr Library·Conceptualized, designed & built bykrin.ai↗
Karlheinz Muhr Library
ArchiveTimelineLibrarian
Sign in
Archive/Murray N. Rothbard
Mensch, Wirtschaft und Staat, Band 2

Murray N. Rothbard · 2021

Mensch, Wirtschaft und Staat, Band 2

94 sections
Ask about this book

About this work

Volume 2 extends Rothbard's price theory into a theory of entrepreneurship, money, and intervention. The market appears not as a static mechanism of distribution, but as a procedure of economic calculation under uncertainty: prices, interest, profit, and loss order scarce means by testing expectations and making misallocations visible. The evenly rotating economy serves only as a limiting case that shows what precisely does not disappear in the real economy.

Denn die GRW bedeutet das Verschwinden der Ungewissheit und der Gewinn ist das Ergebnis der Ungewissheit.

English translation: For the ERE [evenly rotating economy] means the disappearance of uncertainty, and profit is the result of uncertainty.

Profit is therefore not an automatic return to capital, but the result of superior foresight; loss shows that factors of production are more urgently demanded elsewhere. Rothbard thereby shifts the analysis away from class or cost categories and toward entrepreneurial appraisal of future consumer wants.

Das Kapital erzeugt keinen Gewinn. Das tun nur kluge unternehmerische Entscheidungen.

English translation: Capital does not generate profit. Only shrewd entrepreneurial decisions do.

Saving, capital formation, and interest are explained from time preference. Lower time preference lengthens production processes, raises capital equipment and real income; dissaving shortens the structure and consumes wealth. Technology alone therefore does not ground progress if enough saved capital is not available. Chapter 9 applies this connection to factor prices, wages, rents, entrepreneurial income, and location decisions: for Rothbard, distribution is not a subsequent social act, but the pricing of productive services within the production process itself.

Monopoly theory forms the conceptual high point of free-market theory. Cartels, mergers, large firms, advertising, brands, and product differentiation do not count as disturbances of competition so long as they rest on voluntary property and contract. Rothbard rejects the concept of a monopoly price because there is no independently determinable competitive price from which the actual price could deviate.

Es gibt nur den »marktwirtschaftlichen Preis«.

English translation: There is only the »free-market price«.

His critique therefore also targets ideals of perfect competition: the diversity of products, locations, and firm forms is not a defect, but an expression of consumer valuations. Union-enforced wages appear not as productive redistribution, but as restrictive prices that benefit some workers and exclude others. Patents are criticized as state monopoly privileges, while copyright is treated as a contractually grounded property right.

Chapter 11 makes money the medium of the entire analysis. Money is a commodity and a general medium of exchange; its price is purchasing power, not a measurable "price level." Rothbard emphasizes the demand to hold cash, defends so-called hoarding, and denies the neutrality of money. An expansion of the money supply creates no social wealth, but shifts purchasing power toward the early recipients of new money. He therefore criticizes quantity formulas, price indexes, and aggregates such as velocity. Fractional-reserve banks create fiduciary media, whereas genuine money certificates would be fully covered warehouse receipts. Business-cycle theory follows from this: systematic forecasting errors do not arise from the free market, but from credit expansion that pushes the interest rate below the rate determined by time preference.

Chapter 12 draws the political consequence. Rothbard presents intervention as the replacement of voluntary actions by coercion.

Eine Intervention ist das Eindringen von aggressiver physischer Gewalt in die Gesellschaft; zu intervenieren bedeutet, freiwillige Handlungen durch Zwang zu ersetzen.

English translation: An intervention is the intrusion of aggressive physical force into society; to intervene means to replace voluntary actions with coercion.

Price ceilings, minimum wages, exchange controls, licenses, and tariffs generate shortages, surpluses, unemployment, or privileges. Taxation and government spending shift resources from producers to politically preferred uses; without genuine capital accounting, public enterprises lose the standard of rational allocation. Rothbard also interprets depressions not as market failure, but as the necessary liquidation of earlier monetary distortions.

The appendices carry this line against public debt, public goods, and external benefits. Rothbard's systematic point lies in joining price theory, monetary theory, and political economy: market order arises from property, contract, and calculation; intervention damages precisely those price signals on whose functioning it tacitly depends.

Sections

This work was divided into 94 sections when it entered the library's research corpus—an apparatus for search and citation, not necessarily the author's own table of contents. Each title opens its summary.

  1. 1Front Matter and Tables of Contents for Mensch, Wirtschaft und Staat, Volumes 1–3▾
  2. 2Production: Entrepreneurship, Profit and Loss, and the Effect of Net Investment▾
  3. 3Capital Values and Aggregate Profits in a Changing Economy▾
  4. 4Capital Values, Aggregate Profits, and Capital Consumption (continued)▾
  5. 5Capital Accumulation, Technology, Interest, and Uncertainty▾
  6. 6Production: Special Factor Prices and Productive Income — Introduction▾
  7. 7Land, Labor, and Rent▾
  8. 8Land, Labor, Rent, Population, and Differential Rent▾
  9. 9The Nature of Labor and the Labor–Management Dichotomy▾
  10. 10Supply of Land, Land Demand, and Land Speculation▾
  11. 11Labor Supply, Psychic Income, and Differences Among Workers▾
  12. 12Productivity and Marginal Productivity▾
  13. 13Direct and Total Wages; The Problem of Unemployment▾
  14. 14Entrepreneurship and Income: Costs to the Firm▾
  15. 15Entrepreneurship and Income: Costs, Business Income, Calculation, and Vertical Integration▾
  16. 16Economics of Location and Spatial Relations▾
  17. 17Economics of Location: Delivered Prices, Freight Costs, and Land Rent▾
  18. 18The Fallacy of Separating Distribution from Production▾
  19. 19Summary of the Free Market: Factor Prices, Capital, Interest, and Change▾
  20. 20Monopoly and Competition: Individual Self-Sovereignty Rather than Consumer Sovereignty▾
  21. 21Hutt, Consumer Sovereignty, Cartels, and Monopoly Price▾
  22. 22Cartels, Mergers, Partnerships, and Corporations▾
  23. 23Economics, Technology, and the Size of the Firm▾
  24. 24Cartel Instability and Free Competition▾
  25. 25The Large Cartel Problem and the Monopoly Price Question▾
  26. 26Definitions of Monopoly and State Privilege▾
  27. 27The Neoclassical Theory of Monopoly Price▾
  28. 28Consequences of Monopoly Price Theory▾
  29. 29Predatory Pricing and the Alleged Path to Monopoly Price▾
  30. 30The Illusion of Monopoly Price on the Unhampered Market▾
  31. 31Location Monopoly and Spatial Price Differentiation▾
  32. 32Natural Monopoly, Public Utilities, and the Transition to Union Wages▾
  33. 33Restrictive Wage Setting by Trade Unions▾
  34. 34Trade Unions: Restrictive Wages and Critiques of Pro-Union Arguments▾
  35. 35The Theory of Monopolistic or Imperfect Competition▾
  36. 36Multiple Prices and Monopoly▾
  37. 37Multiform Prices and Price Discrimination under Competition▾
  38. 38Patents, Copyrights, and Free-Market Property Rights▾
  39. 39Money and Its Purchasing Power: Introduction▾
  40. 40The Money Relation: Demand for and Supply of Money▾
  41. 41Changes in the Money Relation and the Utility of the Money Stock▾
  42. 42The Demand for Money: Cash Balances, Speculation, and Clearing▾
  43. 43Money Clearing and Cash Demand▾
  44. 44No Unlimited Demand for Money▾
  45. 45Purchasing Power, Interest, Hoarding, and Keynesian Unemployment▾
  46. 46Critique of Keynesian Liquidity Preference▾
  47. 47Purchasing Power and Terms-of-Trade Components of Interest▾
  48. 48Money Supply, Private Coinage, and Money Warehousing▾
  49. 49Fraudulent Money Receipts, 100 Percent Reserves, and Money Substitutes in the Money Supply▾
  50. 50Critiques of 100 Percent Reserves and Gains and Losses from Monetary Change▾
  51. 51Determination of Prices from the Goods Side and the Money Side▾
  52. 52Trade Between Locations, Local Purchasing Power, and Clearing▾
  53. 53Balance of Payments as Consolidated Individual Transactions▾
  54. 54Quasi-Money and Bills of Exchange▾
  55. 55Exchange Rates of Coexisting Moneys and the Beginning of the Critique of the Quantity Equation▾
  56. 56Fallacy of the Quantity Equation▾
  57. 57Measurement Fallacy in the Purchasing Power of Money▾
  58. 58Stabilization Fallacy in the Purchasing Power of Money▾
  59. 59Business Fluctuations and Schumpeter’s Business Cycle Theory▾
  60. 60Further Fallacies of Keynesianism: Interest, Investment, and the Consumption Function▾
  61. 61Critique of the Keynesian Consumption Function▾
  62. 62The Multiplier and the Accelerator Principle Fallacy▾
  63. 63Violent Market Intervention: Introduction and Typology▾
  64. 64Direct Utility Effects of Intervention▾
  65. 65Ex Post Utility, the Free Market, and the State▾
  66. 66Triangular Intervention: Price Control▾
  67. 67Price Controls: Ceilings, Floors, Minimum Wages, and Gresham’s Law▾
  68. 68Product Control, Monopoly Privilege, and the Government Budget▾
  69. 69Taxation: Income Tax, Work Incentives, Saving, and Time Preference▾
  70. 70Attempts at Neutral Taxation▾
  71. 71Neutral Taxation, Progressive Taxation, and Excess Profits Taxes▾
  72. 72Tax Shifting and Incidence for a Tax on One Industry▾
  73. 73Tax Shifting and Incidence of a General Sales Tax▾
  74. 74Land Tax, Georgism, and Taxing Excess Purchasing Power▾
  75. 75Government Spending: Productive Contribution, Transfers, and Free Public Services▾
  76. 76The Fallacy of Government as Entrepreneur▾
  77. 77Government Monopoly Pricing and Calculational Chaos▾
  78. 78Conflict, Command Positions, and State Schooling▾
  79. 79Public Ownership, Social Security, Socialism, and Central Planning▾
  80. 80The Problem of Growth, Forced Saving, and Development Economics▾
  81. 81John Kenneth Galbraith and the Critique of Affluence▾
  82. 82Galbraith, Advertising, Public Sector Scarcity, and Luxury Consumption Continued▾
  83. 83Inflation and Credit Expansion▾
  84. 84Credit Expansion and the Business Cycle▾
  85. 85Secondary Developments in the Business Cycle▾
  86. 86Deflation, Credit Contraction, and the Austrian Business Cycle Theory▾
  87. 87The Limits of Bank Credit Expansion▾
  88. 88Government as Promoter of Credit Expansion▾
  89. 89The Ultimate Limit: The Crack-Up Boom▾
  90. 90Inflation and Compensatory Fiscal Policy▾
  91. 91Conclusion: The Free Market and Coercion▾
  92. 92Appendix A: Government Borrowing▾
  93. 93Appendix B: Collective Goods and External Effects as Arguments for Government Action▾
  94. 94Appendix B Continued: External Benefits, Free Riders, and Subsidies▾

Put a question to this work; the Librarian answers from its 94 sections and cites the passage.

Ask the Librarian