Karlheinz Muhr Library

The Complete “Austrian School of Economics” Collection


© 2026 Karlheinz Muhr Library·Conceptualized, designed & built bykrin.ai↗
Karlheinz Muhr Library
ArchiveTimelineLibrarian
Sign in
Archive/Johann von Komorzynski
Die nationalökonomische Lehre vom Credit

Johann von Komorzynski · 1903

Die nationalökonomische Lehre vom Credit

133 sections
Ask about this book

About this work

Komorzynski, Die nationalökonomische Lehre vom Credit (1909)

Komorzynski’s treatise treats credit not as a merely juridical loan relation, nor as a technical appendage of money, but as a fundamental form of private-economic circulation. Its central thesis is that the “economic essence” of credit can only be grasped after reconstructing the institutions within which it operates: private property, separate household-enterprises, wealth, capital, and income. Credit belongs to the same broad sphere as exchange, because both are ways in which privately separated economic units re-enter social cooperation.

Credit und Tausch bilden zwei verschiedene eigenartige Gestaltungen dieses Verkehres.

English translation: Credit and exchange constitute two different, distinctive forms of this intercourse.

This sentence marks the conceptual hinge of the work. Private property divides society into distinct “Sonderwirtschaften,” each controlling its own means and aims; economic “Verkehr” then reconnects them without abolishing that separation. Exchange corrects one kind of mismatch in the distribution of goods; credit corrects another, especially the temporal mismatch between present command over resources and future productive or income-yielding capacity. Komorzynski’s point is therefore not that credit is exceptional or parasitic, but that it is one of the characteristic mechanisms by which a private-property economy coordinates dispersed economic powers.

The early part of the work is accordingly theoretical rather than descriptive. Komorzynski insists that credit theory cannot begin with banks, bills, or money markets. It must first clarify what it means for an economic subject to possess wealth, to dispose over capital, and to receive income. The concept of income is especially important because credit relations are oriented toward futurity: repayment, yield, or participation depends on the debtor’s or enterprise’s expected future stream of returns.

Die Idee vom Einkommen ist vielmehr völlig unabweislich

English translation: The idea of income is rather wholly indispensable.

Income is thus not an optional accounting refinement. It is the category that makes intelligible why present resources can be transferred against future satisfaction, and why a creditor may rationally relinquish immediate control. Credit presupposes that economic life is not exhausted by existing stocks of goods; it rests on anticipated future proceeds. This is one of Komorzynski’s core conceptual moves: he ties credit to the distinction between Vermögen as a present fund, capital as economically employed wealth, and income as the recurrent outcome toward which economic activity is directed.

From this foundation the work develops a typology. Credit is not reducible to the simple money loan. Once viewed economically, it includes different relations between the provider of resources and the user of them. Komorzynski therefore divides credit into principal forms:

Es scheidet sich hiernach der Credit in zwei Hauptarten.

English translation: Credit accordingly divides into two principal kinds.

The significance of this division is that it separates credit relations according to the creditor’s position in the economic process. In one form, the creditor stands over against the debtor as lender, expecting restitution or an equivalent return. In another, the provider of resources enters into the fortunes of the undertaking itself. Komorzynski captures this distinction sharply:

Der Creditgeber ist hier nicht Darleiher, sondern Gesellschafter.

English translation: Here the credit-giver is not a lender, but a partner.

This formulation shows why the book is more than a theory of lending. It broadens credit into a theory of the ways capital is made available across separate private economies. The “creditor” may remain an external claimant, or may become a participant in enterprise risk and gain. Komorzynski’s analysis therefore connects credit with the organization of production, not merely with consumption smoothing or payment delay.

The relevance of the work lies in this institutional and categorical breadth. Written before later macroeconomic theories of credit creation, it nevertheless resists a narrow monetary interpretation. Credit appears as a social relation mediated by private property: it preserves the autonomy of economic units while enabling resources to move toward uses for which their current owners are not themselves prepared. The work’s enduring interest is its insistence that credit theory must be grounded in the structure of the private economy as a whole. Exchange and credit are parallel forms of coordination; wealth, capital, and income are the categories that explain their function; and the lender-partner distinction reveals the range of economic relations hidden under the single word “Credit.”

Sections

This work was divided into 133 sections when it entered the library's research corpus—an apparatus for search and citation, not necessarily the author's own table of contents. Each title opens its summary.

  1. 1Google public-domain digitization notice and usage guidelines▾
  2. 2Library, title-page, publication, and dedication front matter▾
  3. 3Author’s preface: method and scope of the credit theory▾
  4. 4Errata and corrections▾
  5. 5Table of contents for Part I: the economic essence of credit▾
  6. 6Table of contents for Part II: credit as a national-economic power▾
  7. 7Part I opening: credit as wealth lending and private economic exchange▾
  8. 8General Characterization of Private-Economic Traffic Continued▾
  9. 9Conflict Between Property Law and the Economic Requirements of Goods Distribution▾
  10. 10The Double Task of Private-Economic Traffic▾
  11. 11Conceptual Separation of Private-Economic Traffic: Goods Exchange▾
  12. 12Private-Economic Traffic in the Form of Credit▾
  13. 13The Concept of Credit: General Exposition▾
  14. 14The Concept of Credit: More Precise Delimitation▾
  15. 15Practical Linking of Credit Operations with Exchange Operations▾
  16. 16Credit in Economic Literature as Transfer of Wealth or Capital Use▾
  17. 17Credit as Trust: Literature, Objections, and Critique▾
  18. 18Credit as Temporally Separated Exchange and the Knies-Macleod Debate▾
  19. 19Continuation of the doctrine of credit as temporal exchange▾
  20. 20Critique of credit as temporal exchange and transition to concrete-goods use▾
  21. 21Credit as use-transfer of concrete goods in the literature▾
  22. 22Authors opposing credit as use-transfer of concrete goods▾
  23. 23Komorzynski’s critique of credit as concrete-goods use▾
  24. 24Credit as a force of circulation replacing money▾
  25. 25Critique of credit as circulation power▾
  26. 26Ihering’s concept of credit as money loan▾
  27. 27Critique of Ihering’s money-loan theory and opening of wealth chapter▾
  28. 28The Wealth Character of Goods Possession: Principal Exposition▾
  29. 29Organization of Individual-Economic Goods Possession into Wealth▾
  30. 30Classification of Wealth by Its Different Legal Forms▾
  31. 31Wealth in the Legal Form of the Credit Claim▾
  32. 32Loan Capital as Exchange Good and Commercial Ware▾
  33. 33Economic Literature on the Concept of Wealth: Confusion of Wealth with Goods Stocks▾
  34. 34Erroneous Restriction of Wealth to Goods Possession and Attempts to Extend the Concept▾
  35. 35Wealth Beyond Goods as a Source of Income▾
  36. 36Personal Wealth and Labor Capacity▾
  37. 37Capital as Acquisition Wealth Versus Household Wealth▾
  38. 38The Popular Concept of Capital▾
  39. 39Adam Smith and the Literature on the Capital Concept▾
  40. 40National-Economic Capital Concepts: Replacement, Restriction, and Expansion▾
  41. 41Critiques of expanded capital concepts and capital as goods value▾
  42. 42Limits of defining income as return on wealth▾
  43. 43Deriving the income concept from continuous human needs▾
  44. 44Practical identification of income▾
  45. 45Practical Income Accounting and the Limits of Exchange-Value Wealth Measurement▾
  46. 46Conjunctural Gains, Speculation, Replacement Costs, and Balance-Sheet Valuation▾
  47. 47Income in Economic Literature: Bibliography and the Error of Identifying Income with Goods▾
  48. 48Smith, His Successors, and the Hermann-Schmoller Consumption-Fund Concept of Income▾
  49. 49Smith on Wages, Mistranslation Debates, and the Recurrence Requirement of Income▾
  50. 50Critique of Defining Income as Technical Consumption Goods▾
  51. 51Gross/Net, Necessary/Free, and Original/Derived Income in the Literature▾
  52. 52The Problem of Income: Preface Linking Credit, Wealth, and Income▾
  53. 53Objective Origin and Subjective Allocation of Income▾
  54. 54Justifications of Income Claims Are Not Theoretical Explanations▾
  55. 55Restricting the Income Problem to Income from Goods Ownership▾
  56. 56Recurring Real Increase of Goods as the Genetic Basis of Income▾
  57. 57Private Income as a Complex Technical Result of Countless Goods▾
  58. 58Aggregate Economic Yield as the Common Fund of All Special Income▾
  59. 59Subjective Allocation of Income through Private Power Relations▾
  60. 60The Erroneous Doctrine of Separate Funds for Different Income Types▾
  61. 61The Socialist Exploitation Theory of Capital Yield▾
  62. 62Critique of Exploitation Theory and Menger’s Capital-Use Theory▾
  63. 63Böhm-Bawerk’s Theory of Capital Yield▾
  64. 64Part II Introduction: Credit as an Economic Power▾
  65. 65General Characterization of Credit as a Support for Production and Consumption▾
  66. 66How Credit Promotes Productive Purposes▾
  67. 67How Credit Promotes Consumptive Purposes▾
  68. 68The Distinction between Productive and Consumptive Credit▾
  69. 69Credit as a Means of Saving and Capital Accumulation▾
  70. 70The Danger of Uneconomic Conduct by the Borrower▾
  71. 71Safeguards Against Uneconomic Credit Use and Critique of Credit Restrictions▾
  72. 72The Economic Concept of Usury▾
  73. 73The Canonical Concept of Usury▾
  74. 74Usury as Exceeding a Statutory Maximum Interest Rate▾
  75. 75The Modern Legal Concept of Usury▾
  76. 76The Danger of Economic Interlinking of Interests in Credit▾
  77. 77Credit Claims as Substitutes for Money▾
  78. 78Forms of Money-Saving Business Transactions▾
  79. 79Bills of Exchange as International Means of Payment▾
  80. 80Foreign Exchange Rates and the Causes of Their Fluctuations▾
  81. 81Exchange-Rate Quotation and Local Cash-Value Differentials▾
  82. 82Foreign Exchange Arbitrage and Temporary International Credit▾
  83. 83Erroneous Doctrines Concerning Foreign Exchange Rates▾
  84. 84Introduction to Adapting Circulation Media to Changing Money Demand through Credit▾
  85. 85The Value of Money, the Quantity Theory, and the Postulate of Stability▾
  86. 86Harmful Effects of a Fluctuating Value of Money▾
  87. 87Adjustment of Money Demand and Money Stock without Credit▾
  88. 88Credit Claims and Banknotes as Money Substitutes▾
  89. 89Automatic Regulation and Limits of Banknote Issue▾
  90. 90Opening of the Critique of the Capital-Creating Power of Credit▾
  91. 91Credit Claims Are Not New Capital: Historical Examples from Law to Struensee▾
  92. 92Macleod’s Doctrine of Debt as Immaterial Capital▾
  93. 93Refutations of Credit’s Capital-Creating Power and Its Survival in Goods Theory▾
  94. 94The Error of Value Anticipation in Credit: Concept and Forms▾
  95. 95Authors Teaching Value Anticipation: Soden, Lotz, and Macleod▾
  96. 96Survey of the Doctrine of Value Anticipation in Credit, Continued▾
  97. 97Critique of the Doctrine of Value Anticipation in Credit▾
  98. 98Value Anticipation in the Concept of Wealth▾
  99. 99Economic Organization of Credit: General Character of Societal Credit▾
  100. 100Societies as Juridical Persons or Obligatory Legal Relations▾
  101. 101Special Economic Interests in Societal Credit▾
  102. 102Legal Forms of Capital Association in German, Austrian, French, and English Law▾
  103. 103Continental Forms of Limited Capital Association▾
  104. 104Share Companies, Cooperative Capital, English Company Law, and Transition to Credit Security▾
  105. 105Co-Liability as Legal Security for Credit Claims▾
  106. 106Pledge-Secured Credit, Debtor Disposition, Pawnshop Credit, and Lombard Credit▾
  107. 107Registered Mortgages and Public Land Registers▾
  108. 108Warehouse Goods as Collateral and the Two-Document Warrant System▾
  109. 109Warehouse Receipts, Weightnotes, and the Need to Facilitate Pledge Credit▾
  110. 110Formless Pledge Creation and Statutory Liens in Commercial Credit▾
  111. 111Fixed Mortgage Rank, Owner Mortgage, and Rank Reservation▾
  112. 112The Insufficiency of Cession for Loan-Capital Circulation▾
  113. 113Credit Papers as Embodied and Circulating Loan Capital▾
  114. 114Comparative Law of Negotiable Credit Papers▾
  115. 115Registered Mortgage Transferability and the Legal Regulation of Credit Duration▾
  116. 116Economic Relation of Credit Duration to Investment and Operating Credit▾
  117. 117Rodbertus’s Agricultural Rent-Debt Credit Proposal▾
  118. 118Long-term agricultural credit and rent-estate legislation▾
  119. 119The bank principle, maturity transformation, and reserves▾
  120. 120Credit duration and the interest rate in loan credit▾
  121. 121Legal forms of credit mediation by credit institutions▾
  122. 122Economic advantages of institutional credit mediation▾
  123. 123Active business operations of credit institutions▾
  124. 124Passive business operations, covered bonds, and note issue▾
  125. 125Typology of credit institutions by business type▾
  126. 126Typology of credit institutions by motive and speculative banks▾
  127. 127Speculative Credit Banks and Interest-Spread Intermediation▾
  128. 128Public-Benefit Credit Institutions▾
  129. 129Self-Help Credit Associations: Mutual Liability, Raiffeisen, and Schulze-Delitzsch▾
  130. 130Legal Forms of Credit Institutions▾
  131. 131Index of Cited Authors▾
  132. 132Publisher Catalogue of Related Works▾
  133. 133Digitization and Library End-Matter Metadata▾

Put a question to this work; the Librarian answers from its 133 sections and cites the passage.

Ask the Librarian