Karlheinz Muhr Library

The Complete “Austrian School of Economics” Collection


© 2026 Karlheinz Muhr Library·Conceptualized, designed & built bykrin.ai↗
Karlheinz Muhr Library
ArchiveTimelineLibrarian
Sign in
Archive/Emil Lederer
[Diskussionsbeitrag zum Kohlenbergbau, Bd. II, S. 503, Nr. 47]

Emil Lederer · 1920

[Diskussionsbeitrag zum Kohlenbergbau, Bd. II, S. 503, Nr. 47]

1 sections
Ask about this book

About this work

Emil Lederer: Coal-Mining Commission Intervention (1920)

In this brief recorded commission speaking turn, Lederer characterizes an expropriation proposal as a compromise: immediate expropriation coexists with leaving the works in the former holder’s hands for thirty years.

Das ist ein Kompromiß. Man enteignet heute, beläßt ihm aber das Werk auf 30 Jahre. Dr. Rathenau hat die Idee, er enteignet heute, enteignet aber nicht, sondern erst nach 30 Jahren.

English translation: This is a compromise. One expropriates today, but leaves him the works for thirty years. Dr. Rathenau’s idea is that he expropriates today, yet does not expropriate, but only after thirty years.

The closing paradox distinguishes nominal action from effective change. Lederer’s intervention exposes the temporal ambiguity of Rathenau’s proposal without developing an alternative.

Sections

This work was divided into 1 sections when it entered the library's research corpus—an apparatus for search and citation, not necessarily the author's own table of contents. Each title opens its summary.

  1. 1Critique of Rathenau’s Deferred Expropriation Compromise▾

Put a question to this work; the Librarian answers from its 1 sections and cites the passage.

Ask the Librarian