Karl Theodor von Inama-Sternegg · 1907
In this review of the Italian municipal statistical yearbook’s first issue, Inama-Sternegg treats coordinated urban statistics as both a methodological achievement and evidence of administrative cooperation. His opening judgment establishes the significance of the undertaking:
Die italienische Statistik hat einen großen Fortschritt zu verzeichnen.
English translation: Italian statistics have a great advance to record.
The advance consists in larger Italian municipalities voluntarily adopting a common plan and method for an annual publication. Inama-Sternegg credits the Florentine municipal administration, especially Mayor Marchese Ippolito Niccolini and statistician Ugo Giusti, with organizing this collaboration. He endorses the participating mayors’ expectation that the yearbook would encourage greater uniformity in local administration and strengthen ties among municipalities. Statistical comparability thus has an institutional purpose beyond the accumulation of information.
The review moves from the organization of the enterprise to a detailed survey of its coverage. Government agencies supplied meteorological, demographic, postal, fiscal, and municipal-enterprise data; municipal administrations furnished the remaining material. Although 108 cities completed questionnaires, coverage varied considerably by subject. Inama-Sternegg records these differences rather than treating participation as uniformly comprehensive: building activity, housing, sanitation, water supply, and lighting each drew responses from different numbers of cities. This accounting gives substance to his favorable assessment while revealing the limits of the first survey.
His treatment of markets illustrates the yearbook’s combination of administrative infrastructure and measurable urban consumption:
Das Kapitel über die Märkte behandelt die allgemeinen Lebensmittelmärkte (73 Städte), die Viehmärkte (54 Städte), die öffentlichen Schlachthäuser (85 Städte) und den mittleren Jahresverbrauch der wichtigsten Lebensmittel für den Einwohner berechnet von 69 Städten.
English translation: The chapter on the markets deals with the general foodstuff markets (73 cities), the cattle markets (54 cities), the public slaughterhouses (85 cities), and the mean annual consumption of the most important foodstuffs per inhabitant, calculated for 69 cities.
The survey then extends through education, libraries, museums, cultural expenditure, poor relief, hospitals, and mutual-aid societies, before reaching policing, fire protection, transport, and municipal finance. Its breadth makes urban life legible through institutions, services, expenditure, and use. Inama-Sternegg particularly values material that goes beyond aggregate totals: historical notes on cultural institutions, details of welfare provision, and information about administration and costs.
Finance provides an especially strong example of the publication’s comparative reach:
Die Finanzen der italienischen Städte (Einnahmen, Ausgaben, Schuldenwesen) sind in allen wesentlichen Beziehungen von fast allen Städten nachgewiesen; insbesondere die Tabellen über Steuern und Gebühren, über die städtischen Bediensteten und Pensionisten sind reichlich ausgestaltet.
English translation: The finances of the Italian cities (revenues, expenditures, indebtedness) are shown in all essential respects for almost all the cities; the tables on taxes and fees and on the municipal employees and pensioners in particular are amply elaborated.
The concluding assessment turns the successful production of statistics into evidence about the municipalities themselves. Despite the uneven subject-level returns documented earlier, Inama-Sternegg praises the broad participation as a sign of orderly administration, recognition of the undertaking’s usefulness, and patriotic cooperation. He also identifies Giusti’s planning and concise chapter introductions as guarantees of continued development. The review’s central conceptual move is to connect standardized knowledge with civic capacity: the yearbook matters both for what it reveals about Italian cities and for the cooperative administrative culture its compilation demonstrates.
This work was divided into 1 sections when it entered the library's research corpus—an apparatus for search and citation, not necessarily the author's own table of contents. Each title opens its summary.
Put a question to this work; the Librarian answers from its 1 sections and cites the passage.
Ask the Librarian